Saving Grace by Dr Simon Thurley
Parish churches are a quintessential feature of the English landscape, but many face a perilous future.
Dr Simon Thurley
© English Heritage
© English Heritage
Next to the English Heritage site of Lyddington Bede House in Rutland is St Andrew’s church, set in its graveyard. This is a quintessentially English sight. On the Continent, it is rare; the dead are normally buried in separate cemeteries on the outskirts and the church sits squarely in the middle of the village, not in a separate compound. Unlike our Continental cousins, the English have tended to build communities round their burial grounds. The buildings themselves are different, too. In France, Germany or Italy, you always enter a church at its west end through one of three portals that generally relate to the nave and the aisles. By contrast, English parish churches are usually entered through a large porch on the north or south side, as at St Mary’s church, Berry Pomeroy in Devon. In the Middle Ages, many legal transactions were executed at the church door, including marriages. In the English climate, a porch was essential to provide shelter for the villagers. Inside, our churches are roofed with timber – rather than the stone or plaster vaults usually found on the Continent. Many, such as the ceiling of St Michael and all Angels, Tettenhall in Staffordshire, are highly decorated, carved and usually painted. The timber roofs also give English churches a different external appearance, with low-pitched roofs, mostly hidden behind battlements, as at St Peter’s in Walls End, Tyne and Wear. Finally, there is the peculiarly English flat-topped tower that characterises so many parish churches and the square-ended, rather than apsidal (semi-circular), chancels, both features seen at St Peter’s in Tawstock, Devon.
But it is not just parish churches that are particularly English. A strong case can be made for our 17 medieval cathedrals. They are all complexes of buildings, rather than the very large, isolated churches found on the Continent, where cathedrals were not part of monasteries. By contrast, about half of English cathedrals were – and those that were not still adopted monastic architectural forms. So, while Lincoln Cathedral, for instance, was not a monastic foundation, it still has a cloister and an enormous chapter house. Moreover, English cathedral complexes were set, like parish churches, in graveyards. These graveyards, now transformed into cathedral closes, acquired the houses of the canons and other cathedral staff around them. The close, as a setting for a cathedral with its chapter house and cloister, is thus a purely English conception. On the Continent, it is usual to turn the corner of a street and be confronted by the vast bulk of a cathedral sprouting out of the townscape. This is famously the case in Florence.
St Bartholomew's, Churchdown, Gloucestershire
© English Heritage/Boris Baggs
© English Heritage/Boris Baggs
Since 1991, English Heritage has awarded £41.8 million in grants to English cathedrals in order to make up some of the £164m maintenance deficit identified that year. Most of that work is now completed and most cathedrals, unlike the vast majority of our parish churches, are well visited by tourists and have a significant income. Yet we cannot be complacent; these great and very English edifices require continuous work if they are to be enjoyed by future generations. We all have a responsibility to help keep them up.
© Dr Simon Thurley. A version of this article was published in the June 2003 issue of Heritage Today.
- English Heritage's Inspired! campaign is the most strategic and ambitious attempt yet to tackle the problems facing this country's 14,500 historic places of worship and is supported by all the faith groups with listed buildings in England. For more information about Inspired! visit www.english-heritage.org.uk/inspired